12 Angry Men (1957)
It's hard to explain why, but I really like courtroom dramas. Maybe it's the figure of the prosecution attorney trying his best to bring justice to the table (see Paul Newman in the excellent The Verdict ), or the defense attorney fighting with all his might to release the defendant we as the audience know is innocent (e.g. Gregory Peck in To Kill a Mockingbird , a movie loved by many, many people -- myself included --, but clearly not by Ebert), or maybe the battle of wits between both sides (check out Spencer Tracy and Fredric March in the superb Inherit the Wind ). Well, Sidney Lumet 's 12 Angry Men has nothing of the above. Well, not explicitly, at least. Based on a 1954 teleplay by Reginald Rose, the movie starts when the trial per se is over, with the judge addressing the jurors before their deliberation. The accusing parties seem happy, as if a guilty verdict was certain; the defense lawyer, leaving the courtroom, seems to have had a difficult time durin...